Select Page

Being treated as pariahs – challenging the mental health of Victorians!

Written by Leonie Saunders

Benevolent dictator of Connecting the Dots, proud lefty feminist. Adore children & animals. Despise greedy union bashing power abusing corp polluters.

August 26, 2020

Human beings are a social species. We are hard wired to social interaction, cooperation and reciprocity. It is elemental to maintaining our mental health and our survival as a species.

As a Victorian, enduring the isolation of lockdown has so many challenges including keeping ones mental health in check. This is particularly relevant given the uncharitable provincialism expressed daily on the mainstream media by the premiers of Queensland, N.S.W et al. People living alone having to cope with with isolation is one thing, but trying daily not to internalise the fact that we Victorians are being treated as pariahs, cut off from our families due to imaginary lines on a map exposes the chinks in the armour of our Federation.

Unfortunately Victorians in lockdown are captive to news reported by callow journalists employed to deliver news on the cheap by the owners of this country’s mainstream news media outlets. And if that isn’t bad enough, there is the pitiable reporting coming from the ABC’s news 24 department that construes balanced journalism as employing right wing talking heads reporting news with a clear Liberal bias.

As it stands now, other than turning off the news completely. It is impossible to ignore the unchallenged snide comments and finger pointing emanating from Sydney’s other lethal spider, Scott Morrison. 

It is much to my chagrin that press gallery journalists do not hold power to account. Perhaps its all in the name, because even in the face of obvious government corruption. They consistently allow Morrison to get off scot free. 

Seeing the Prime Minister smirk in to the camera as he, without any compunction whatsoever, shoves the buck for his governments failures safeguarding the health and wellbeing of the elderly on to the Victorian government is infuriating. Then on top of that trying to cope mentally with the sickening parochialIsm coming from the other State Premiers; the worst being Annastacia Palaszczuk. The disparaging subtext contained in their comments makes it more than evident to Victorians that contrary to the “we are all in this together” spin. We know that Australians are NOT all in this together.

On any assessment, it is the epitome of bloody-minded cynicism that with an election imminent, Palaszczuk is exploiting COVID-19 for her own political purposes. Following closely behind Palaszczuk in the ‘We are NOT really in this altogether stakes‘, is N.S.W Premier Gladys Berejiklian, Vying for third place is the Northern Territories newly re-elected Chief Minister Michael Gunner and the Premier of South Australia, Steven Marshall.  Coming close behind is Tasmania’s Peter Gutwein. And as for the W.A Premier Mark McGowan, well having lived in Perth for many years. It is not surprising to me that his political fortunes have skyrocketed. After all COVID-19 provided him the opportunity to reassert the desire of the states Sandgropers to keep W.A free of the rabble from the east. 

While it is generally understood that as a federation, the greater good can only ever be achieved when we as a nation work together in the common good to improve the wellbeing of our whole society. Sadly COVID-19 has shone a light on the soft underbelly of Australia’s federation. It challenges the very notion of social solidarity in the collective good of all Australians. We need only look at the water plundered in the north that is axiomatic of the appalling mismanagement of the Murray-Darling to know that State politicians do not consider the common good in terms of all Australians. To them the common good will always be defined by lines on a map, not as a whole.  

Unfortunately, the law of the instrument governing the behaviour of state politicians does not bode well for the future of our nation. So long as the states view ‘the greater good’ only in parochial terms, doubling down to serve their own self interest, alienating Australians from Australians. Make no mistake, when the horrors of human accelerated global warming that loom ominously come into full effect, No technological advancement will save us from Mother Nature’s wrath, and the ensuing backlash of a nation divided will doubtless lead to the breakdown of civil society. 

And therein lies the rub. 

Is it any wonder people living outside of Australia reading and watching the news online as reported via this country’s mainstream news media outlets are justifiably disconcerted by what they are observing taking place in our country. The apparent dysfunction that exists within our federation sparks statements such as, I thought Scott Morrison was the Prime Minister of the entire nation. This is generally followed rhetorically with the question; isn’t Victoria an integral part of Australia’s federation? 

Then when seeing the arrogance of the Prime Minister smirking on the news, and knowing the history behind his ability to set the media’s daily agenda was made easier by Labor Party’s antipathy towards the establishment class owners of Fairfax newspapers, irks me no end. That during the late 1980’s Bob Hawke and Paul Keating did a deal with the devil in the lead up to getting Labor’s Cross Media Ownership Legislation passed by the Parliament that gave the newspaper publisher the power to control the circulation of over 70% of the entire nations metropolitan and regional newspapers is indefensible. 

And yet despite all the evidence that tells me otherwise. I still want to believe that had Hawke and his treasurer Keating had a skerrick of nous and forethought as to the ramifications of their legislative changes to Australia’s mainstream print and broadcast media outlets. They would not have willingly concentrated media power into the hands of two filthy rich bully’s. One being Kerry Packer, an overbearing self-confessed tax dodger, and the other Rupert Murdoch, a megalomaniacal puppet master.

Sadly, Labor’s penchant for self-destruction as evident in the changes to media laws in the 1990’s and the abolition of industry wide bargaining. Opened the way for Howard to consolidate Murdoch’s power even further. All together, the decisions made by the Labor Government followed by Howard have dramatically undermined Australian democracy.  To such an extent that non-unionised workplaces and self-censorship are commonplace for journalists in the employ of Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp papers. The same goes for the commentariat employed by Murdoch and a likeminded coterie of rightwing owners of the country’s other broadcast news media outlets. For young ambitious journalists soft peddling where Scott Morrison and his ministers are concerned is a matter of survival.

There are copious ways broadcasters promulgate their pernicious political influence. To be more specific, owners of newspapers hand-pick editors, likewise the producers in television and radio are hand-picked by CEO’s who share the same political mindset as their company board of directors. This ensures the upper echelons of corporate Australia always control the narrative in the content of the copy written by journalists and the context in which opinions wrapped up and framed as questions are in keeping with their capitalist owners political agenda.

Notwithstanding the pressure to conform, journalists of quality and integrity understand that in a democracy their primary obligation is to the public. They know the public’s right to be fully informed accurately and without bias is a precondition of being granted privileged access to power. Whereas sadly for many young ambitious journalists succumbing to the pressure of operating in a concentrated media environment are destined to see the world through the lens of their proprietors right wing bias. Tragically, the instant they succumb, they make themselves unworthy of those privileges as partisanship on the part of news journalists is the antithesis of their role and responsibilities in a democracy.  

Of most significance to the undermining of democracy is the way in which the nations press gallery journos consistently fail to forensically examine the Prime Minister on the details contained in his governments policy decisions. Not only during the pandemic, but overall. The lack of media scrutiny in a democracy contributes significantly to Australians never knowing the full extent to which their policies have a detrimental effect on the health and wellbeing of our society.

For intelligent free thinking Victorians it is beyond reprehensible that in the midst of the pandemic the press gallery grant the Prime Minister enough unchallenged air time so as to allow him to shove the buck of his and his governments mismanagement on to the broad shoulders of Victoria’s Daniel Andrews. To say the media’s reporting by young overly ambitious political neophytes is wearing thin would be an understatement..

Under the circumstances, maintaining any semblance of sanity I have to trust that outside the borders of Australia’s most progressive state. There lives a multitude of socially conscious, politically literate Australians alert to Scott Morrison’s modus operandi. For the sake of my sanity, I have to trust that in spite of his best attempts to shift focus away from the fact that as the regulatory authority and bestower of public monies to private owners in the for profit aged care sector. COVID-19 has awakened the majority of my fellow Australians to the ruthless socio-economics of neoliberalIsm as implemented by Morrison and his ministers.

Of course, the Liberal Party’s biggest donors being business lobbies. It is not happenstance that Scott Morrison subscribes to the ideology of small government underpinning deregulation and privatisation as championed by the IPA’s monopoly capitalists. The federal government‘s overarching protection racket for the profit takers is directly responsible for the disgraceful neglect of essential safeguards to protect the health and wellbeing of the elderly in private aged care facilities. One can only hope, as a consequence of COVID-19 Australians are taking heed of the Prime Ministers words and actions that reveal his deep rooted mean-spiritedness. If there is any justice post Rona, the lies told by him and his cabinet of freeloaders will be his governments undoing.

Observing the pitiful inadequacy of Albanese and his shadow Cabinets performance is adding to my general despondency.  Watching Albanese put himself forward as the 2nd coming of Mr. Consensus, banking on the government’s fortunes changing so that Labor can win high office by default is lamentable. Notwithstanding the fact that seeing, hearing and reading the mainstream media’s rightwing attack dog journalists going for the Victorian Premiers jugular while simultaneously acting as accomplices in the Prime Minister efforts to hoodwink Australians is infuriating. It is indeed problematic for Labor that during this crisis Coal loving Joel Fitzgibbon can capture a minute of limelight by raising his ugly destabilising head. Yet Albanese has not be able to find a way to cut through to make his mark as a potential leader of the nation. Obviously Albanese is being ill-advised. Albanese thus far hasn’t had the mettle to show the same loyalty to Victoria’s Dan Andrews as Morrison has shown to his states Premier Gladys Berejiklian.  

Where Australia’s opaque Prime Minister is given a free ride in the media. Victoria’s Premier Dan Andrews fronts up to answer loaded questions from a baying pack of Murdoch’s News Corp journalists. He does not shirk the moral responsibility of his position as Premier, and it is to his credit that he takes responsibility where it is not his to take.

Which brings me to the fundamentals of our democracy.

Under the Westminster System representative democracy ministerial responsibility is a constitutional convention. However, inscrutable changes in our polity in recent history are clearly irreconcilable with these conventions consistent with the democratic precepts of open and accountable government. 

Irrespective of the jurisdiction, one of the major causes for the publics general distrust of this nations political class is due to neither federal nor state ministers having due respect for the Westminster systems convention that behoves all in high office to take moral responsibility for failing to adequately discharge their duties. Ministerial mea culpas is not accountability, it’s lip service. The only way Cabinet ministers can demonstrate accountability is by way of resigning from the executive.  Thus the system is now completely broken.

From a big picture perspective, the ultimate responsibility for the global pandemic is capitalism and the systemic embrace of supply-side neoliberalism. For this alone, the Prime Minister must held to account for his incautious push to open up the national economy driven by an unquestioning adherence to neoliberalism and the capitalist tenets of unrestrained growth.

Let me be clear, profitability  is the primary driver of Australia’s private sector aged care homes. They are a federal government responsibility. The federal governments Health Minister Greg Hunt and the Minister for Ageing, Richard Coldbeck bear ultimately responsibility for the tragic deaths of our elderly citizens in these ill-equiped unwholesome institutions. If either of these men had a soupçon of morality and human decency they would resign post haste.  Had these Ministers been less concerned with adhering to their party’s economic doctrine and actually cared for the health and safety of the elderly many of these deaths could have been avoided.

The truth is we as a society have been hoodwinked into believing that private ownership is more efficient than public ownership. Whereas years of evidence shows this couldn’t be further from the truth. Unfortunately, the sophistry of efficiency gains that slides like honey off the tongues of government ministers and business owners continues to hold sway in the general publics mindset.

One of the primary reasons successive Coalition governments have cleared the way for corporations and churches in the aged care industry to employ an under-trained casual workforce is to curtail the labour cost of employing full-time qualified nurses to care for the elderly. Employing casuals acts as an impediment to unionism in workplaces. Which of course is the  neoliberal orthodoxy  central to the Coalition governments much heralded cutting red tape narrative that allows profit takers to self regulate. 

Cutting red tape has enabled private security firms to adopt a skim off the top business model of employing sub-contractors who they know utilise untrained staff. It is not as if politicians and departmental bureaucrats don’t know sub-contracting to cut costs forms the basis of the business model adopted by large security firms. And this is why the ultimate responsibility for Victoria‘s hotel quarantine fiasco rests on the shoulders of Jenny Mikakos. Mikakos willingly took on the roles as Victoria’s Minister for Health, Minister for Ambulance Services and Minister for the Coordination of Health and Human Services COVID-19 as well as Deputy Leader of the Government. And she has been shown to have failed significantly in performing her duties In her portfolios as Minister for Health and even more so in the Coordination of Health and Human Services COVID-19.

Like Hunt and Colbeck federally, as a Cabinet minister Mikakos bears the ultimate responsibility for the actions of her ministry’s oversight on the relative departments. If Mikakos had a modicum of integrity, rather than allow her leader to bear the burden of answering for her erroneous decisions; she would fall on her sword. 

Considering the cautionary advice given by experts in the realm of psychology who warn that one of the prime causes of depression and anxiety is anger turned inward. We can view as inevitable that the sneering parochialism voiced by the Prime Minister and State Government Premiers will on a subliminal level have long term deleterious effects on the collective mental heath of my states citizenry.

COVID-19 has certainly exposed the worst of Australia’s unsophisticated provincialism that has long had its political impetus in the right-wing ranks of Sydney’s smug ruling class. I fear the chinks in the armour of Australia’s federation will need serious panel beating to repair the subliminal substructure in the psychology of a state that has been alienated from the rest of the nation to which it is suppose to belong.

1 Comment

  1. Michele O'Brien

    Brilliant writing and opinion, Leonie. I hope there are people out there who read your piece and spread it far and wide and, hopefully, create some positive influence. Our country and citizens so desparately need it. Brava sister, Michele


Leave a Reply

You May Also Like …

The Big Lie.

The Big Lie.

A little over two weeks have passed since I listened intently to the presenter of the ABC’s Statewide Drive program...

Democracy in name only!

Democracy in name only!

According to the Guardian’s Christopher Knaus, analysis of donation disclosures suggests about 114 companies and lobby...

Share This
%d bloggers like this: